Table of Contents
Although helicopter parents have earned quite a negative reputation in mainstream media, researchers have not found consistently negative impacts on children. Some studies actually found that this parenting style could produce favorable results in grown children due to the parents’ intense support1. Find out the pros and cons of this parenting style.
The inconsistency is mainly caused by the fact that “helicopter parenting” is not a well defined term in psychology. Unlike the four Baumrind parenting styles, there isn’t an universally agreed upon definition on what constitutes helicopter parenting. As a result, various studies using different definitions arrived at different conclusions on its effects.
Fortunately, by inspecting the different interpretations, researchers have found that it’s not the amount of involvement, but the type of involvement, that determines whether the “helicoptering” will benefit or harm the kid2.
This is good news to protective parents because they can fine-tune their parenting into the type that helps, and not impedes, their children’s healthy development.
What is Helicopter Parenting
Helicopter parents are loosely defined as parents who pay excessive attention to their children’s every move and experience. They are highly involved, overprotective parents who tirelessly oversee every aspect of their children’s lives and sometimes even act on their behalf. They are sometimes called cosseting parents.
These parents are so named because they hover over their children and make noise like a helicopter, and they swoop in to rescue the kids at the first sign of trouble.
Originally, the term “helicopter parenting” signals that the parent is among the Baby Boomers (i.e. born between 1940s to 1960s), and the children are members of the Millennial generation (born between 1980s to 2000s). This term gained attention and notoriety in the early 2000s just as the millennials began reaching college age. College admission officials and professors started experiencing the parents’ intrusive behavior and denouncing it publicly.
These parents are infamous for practices such as sitting in on the child’s admission interview, calling school administrators at 11pm to report a mouse in their child’s dorm room, and complaining to the professor about a disappointing grade their kid has received. Hovering parents cannot let go of their kids3.
In recent years, this term is also used to describe parents of any generation who show excessive monitoring and protective behavior in ways inappropriate for their child’s developmental stage.
Signs of A Helicopter Parent
One of the characteristics of helicopter parents is that the parents micromanage their children’s life. While young children do require parents’ supervision, control and guidance to learn the rules of the world, these parents do it at a developmentally inappropriate level.
Helicopter parents monitor their children constantly. They control their children’s behavior and insist on helping with tasks their children should be capable of doing alone. When their children face the slightest obstacle, they dive in to rescue immediately.
Here are some examples of helicopter parenting in different stages of a child’s life.
In toddlerhood, it makes sense to protect little kids from danger. However, over-involved parents might shadow their little ones incessantly. When the kid plays with a new toy, they shows their kids the “right” way to play with it and correct them if the kid tries to use it in a different way. The kid doesn’t have the space or opportunity to try and figure things out on their own. When the kid plays with other kids, these parents direct the child’s behavior and how they should interact with others.
Falling and getting scratches are a normal part of toddlerhood as the kid learns to walk, but the parents hover over their toddlers to avoid any minor accident. A mildly scraped knee can stress out them intensely.
In elementary school, this parent goes to great lengths to get their kid into a certain school or a certain teacher. They not only supervise, but also help their kid complete their school work or projects.
A helicopter parent selects their child’s friends and activities for them. Their kids’ preferences are usually not taken into account because they believe they know what’s the best for their children.
In high school, the parent might take on the responsibility of researching and selecting the universities for their child to apply to. They watch over their kid’s shoulder when the kid applies to colleges. They may even call the admission office for an explanation if their child has not gotten into their dream school.
In college, the parent might request an extension for their child or complete assignments for them. They contact the president of the university, the dean, or the professor to dispute their child’s poor grades. They may even attend job fairs and interview with their child4.
The Effects of Helicopter Parenting
Despite the lopsided negative portrayal in popular media, a number of studies have found both positive and negative results associated with helicopter parenting.
Pros – Advantages of Protective Parenting
Educators have long accepted that parental participation in the educational experiences of their children is a good thing. Appropriate parent involvement is one of the benefits of helicopter parenting. It is critical to a student’s intellectual and emotional development, and academic success5.
Research has found that a parent’s involvement fosters more positive attitudes in the kid toward school, improves homework habits, reduces absenteeism and dropping out, and enhances academic achievement6.
At the university level, some studies have noted parental involvement has positive impacts on student development areas such as alcohol, decision making skills, life skills, health issues, and career development7.
Intense support from these parents in areas including financial, advice and emotional has also proven to be valuable. Grown children who have received such intense support have better psychological adjustment and life satisfaction compared to those who have not.
Cons – Disadvantages of Over-Protective Parenting
Despite the findings on parental involvement, multiple studies have indicated that over-parenting can result in children’s mental health problems.
Children whose parents involve in their education at developmentally inappropriate levels are found to have worse psychological health. They are more prone to anxiety and depression, and substance abuse8.
Adolescents and young adults are particularly affected. These children are shielded from the difficulties in realities since they were little kids. Studies have found that they tend to be more neurotic and have a harder time becoming independent. They have low self-esteem and poor coping skills to deal with problems in everyday lives9.
In adult children, helicopter parenting is also associated with higher levels of narcissism and sense of entitlement10.
Because these parents are the driving force behind education seeking, their children have extrinsic motivation to learn, which is found to be associated with lower academic performance11.
Is Helicopter Parenting Good or Bad
So why is there a big divergence in the results of helicopter parenting studies?
On the surface, it seems the amount or the level of a parent’s involvement could be the determining factor in whether such engagement would benefit their kid.
But it turns out the discrepancies between different findings lie in the type of parental involvement as perceived by the child. This phenomenon can be explained by the Self-determination Theory.
According to the Self-determination Theory, there are three basic human psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness12.
When these needs are met, an individual experiences better health and well-being. They are intrinsically motivated to achieve and able to undergo growth and development13.
A supportive family environment, one that provides autonomous support to the kid can satisfy those needs. Autonomy supportive parents allow children to take an active role in solving their own problems, leading to competence which means feeling confident in their ability to effectively interact with their environment. This type of parenting leads to better social and emotional adjustment in children. On the other hand, a family environment that doesn’t allow autonomy cannot meet those needs14.
Being autonomy supportive doesn’t mean allowing the kid to behave any way they want. It means the child perceives the parent as non-controlling and they encourage autonomy.
“Helicoptering” can be beneficial if the kid experiences it as supportive and not controlling. But if children’s experiences are perceived as being controlled, it doesn’t matter whether the parent is supportive because without autonomy, the child won’t flourish in their development.
How To Stop Helicopter Parenting
Most parents who “helicopter” have good intentions. They want their children to be healthy, happy and successful. They want to help and support their kids in their parenting journey.
However, such parent is often perfectionist who makes their kid’s success their parenting priority. They become an overly involved parent. As a result, their “help” or “support” becomes controlling.
To break free from helicopter parenting, draw the line between helping and controlling. It’s great to be a helpful and supportive parent as long as we don’t cross the line and start directing, or worse dictating, our children’s every move.
A low grade, a wrong college, being rejected from a sports team or a botched job interview will not ruin our kids’ future. On the contrary, they are great lessons our children can learn from, with our guidance and support.
Being a controlling parent not only impacts the child’s wellbeing negatively, but it also causes a rift in the parent-child relationship. A warm, caring and happy childhood is actually the best predictor of a child’s future success.
Final Thoughts On Helicopter Parents
There is nothing wrong to want to be a better parent. However, the desire to raise successful kids or constant comparison with other parents can push parents to become overly involved hurting our children’s development.
- 1.Fingerman KL, Cheng Y-P, Wesselmann ED, Zarit S, Furstenberg F, Birditt KS. Helicopter Parents and Landing Pad Kids: Intense Parental Support of Grown Children. Journal of Marriage and Family. Published online July 13, 2012:880-896. doi:10.1111/j.1741-3737.2012.00987.x
- 2.Schiffrin HH, Liss M, Miles-McLean H, Geary KA, Erchull MJ, Tashner T. Helping or Hovering? The Effects of Helicopter Parenting on College Students’ Well-Being. J Child Fam Stud. Published online February 9, 2013:548-557. doi:10.1007/s10826-013-9716-3
- 3.Coburn KL. Organizing a ground crew for today’s helicopter parents. About Campus. Published online July 2006:9-16. doi:10.1002/abc.167
- 4.Vinson K. Hovering Too Close: The Ramifications of Helicopter Parenting in Higher Education. Georgia State University Law Review. 2013;29:423.
- 5.Jeynes WH. The Relationship Between Parental Involvement and Urban Secondary School Student Academic Achievement. Urban Education. Published online January 2007:82-110. doi:10.1177/0042085906293818
- 6.Sui-Chu EH, Willms JD. Effects of Parental Involvement on Eighth-Grade Achievement. Sociology of Education. Published online April 1996:126. doi:10.2307/2112802
- 7.Carney-Hall KC. Understanding current trends in family involvement. New Directions for Student Services. Published online 2008:3-14. doi:10.1002/ss.271
- 8.LeMoyne T, Buchanan T. DOES “HOVERING” MATTER? HELICOPTER PARENTING AND ITS EFFECT ON WELL-BEING. Sociological Spectrum. Published online July 2011:399-418. doi:10.1080/02732173.2011.574038
- 9.Odenweller KG, Booth-Butterfield M, Weber K. Investigating Helicopter Parenting, Family Environments, and Relational Outcomes for Millennials. Communication Studies. Published online July 28, 2014:407-425. doi:10.1080/10510974.2013.811434
- 10.Segrin C, Woszidlo A, Givertz M, Montgomery N. Parent and Child Traits Associated with Overparenting. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology. Published online June 2013:569-595. doi:10.1521/jscp.2013.32.6.569
- 11.Schiffrin HH, Liss M. The Effects of Helicopter Parenting on Academic Motivation. J Child Fam Stud. Published online February 6, 2017:1472-1480. doi:10.1007/s10826-017-0658-z
- 12.Deci EL, Ryan RM. The “What” and “Why” of Goal Pursuits: Human Needs and the Self-Determination of Behavior. Psychological Inquiry. Published online October 2000:227-268. doi:10.1207/s15327965pli1104_01
- 13.Ryan RM, Deci EL. Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivations: Classic Definitions and New Directions. Contemporary Educational Psychology. Published online January 2000:54-67. doi:10.1006/ceps.1999.1020
- 14.Deci EL, Ryan RM. The Paradox of Achievement. In: Improving Academic Achievement. Elsevier; 2002:61-87. doi:10.1016/b978-012064455-1/50007-5